Is Mussina a Hall of Famer?

Baseball Betting Lines

11/20/2008 - (Sportsbook Betting Lines) - The worst-kept secret in baseball started to leak out on Wednesday, when it was revealed that right-hander Mike Mussina was indeed going to hang up his spikes after 18 seasons.

The news certainly comes as no shock, as the Yankees have been operating under the assumption that Mussina would not be returning since the season ended. It was never about coming back this season for him, it would have been about coming back for at least three more seasons to make a run at 300 wins.

If he had returned next year and had another good year, he would have owed it to himself to go after 300. In the end, he wasn't ready for that kind of commitment.

Now the question becomes, is Mike Mussina a Hall of Famer?

He will end his career at 270-153 with an earned run average of 3.68 and 2,813 strikeouts. However, he led the league in wins just once, and finished in the top-3 of AL Cy Young voting one time.

Mussina, who turns 40 next month, also won 20 games just one time in his career - this past season - but won 19 games twice and 18 on three other occasions.

According to the Elias Sports Bureau, he is just the fifth pitcher since 1900 to win 20 games or more in the final season of his career - and the first since Sandy Koufax in 1967.

Also, keep in mind that of the 25 pitchers to have won 270 games since 1900, only five - Lefty Grove, Christy Mathewson, Roger Clemens, Randy Johnson and Grover Cleveland Alexander - have a higher winning percentage than Mussina's .638.

All are either in the Hall of Fame or will be there soon enough.

Mussina also spent his entire career in the AL East, during the steroid era, and something should be said for that. But then again, he also played on teams that made the playoffs nine times in his 18-year career and only played on four clubs that finished below .500.

He's very comparable to a guy like Tom Glavine, who, of course, has won over 300 games, but played four more seasons and, like Mussina, pitched on great teams throughout his career.

Glavine, though, is a two-time Cy Young Award winner and finished in the top-3 four other times. He is a lock for the Hall, but is he that much better than Mussina, if at all?

Sure he had five seasons with at least 20 wins, but had far more mediocre campaigns than Mussina, who, if anything, was remarkably consistent throughout his 18-year career.

Actually if Glavine had retired the season before he turned 40, like Mussina is doing, he would have ended with 270 wins and probably would have found himself outside looking in his quest for the Hall.

So Glavine, like countless others, gets rewarded for hanging on just to compile some stats, and Mussina gets punished because he knew when enough was enough. Is there any doubt that Mussina would get to 300 wins if he hung around for another three or four years with the Yankees?

Granted, I don't think either one of them are Hall of Famers, but if Glavine gets in, you have to put Mussina in. By the way, should that happen and they both get in, someone owes Bert Blyleven and Jack Morris a huge apology.

Debates like this are what separates the Baseball Hall of Fame from the others. Normally, though, I work under the assumption that if it is as much of a debate as this seems to be, then he probably shouldn't be in the Hall of Fame.

Roultette Baseball Betting News


<< Flames, Avs cap home-and-home in Denver
(Sportsbook Betting Lines) - The Calgary Flames had no trouble against the Colorado Avalanche at home this season. They will now try to carry that success into Denver tonight, as the two teams wrap a home-and-home set at the Pepsi Center. The Flames h

<< Steelers Look to Knock Out Last-Place Bengals
(Sportsbook Betting Lines) - The Pittsburgh Steelers will look to remain above the fray in the AFC North on Thursday night, when Mike Tomlin's team welcomes the struggling Cincinnati Bengals to Heinz Field. Pittsburgh opens Week 12 with a one-game adv

<< Trying to match season-high win streak, Wild host Canucks
(Sportsbook Betting Lines) - The Minnesota Wild will try to match their longest winning streak of the season tonight, when they host the Vancouver Canucks in a Northwest Division showdown at Xcel Energy Center. Vancouver and the Wild will battle for f

<< Sens hope to end skid versus slumping Habs
(Sportsbook Betting Lines) - The Ottawa Senators will try for their first win in two weeks when they invite the struggling Montreal Canadiens for tonight's Northeast Division matchup at Scotiabank Place. The Senators have lost five straight contests s

<< Thrashers, Pens both try to get back in win column
(Sportsbook Betting Lines) - A pair of teams who recently had long winning streaks snapped will meet tonight in Atlanta, as the Thrashers welcome the Pittsburgh Penguins to Philips Arena. The Penguins had won six straight before being dealt a shootout

Nalbandian-Ferrer will open Davis Cup final >>
Mar del Plata, Argentina (Sportsbook Betting Lines) - When the 2008 Davis Cup final between host Argentina and Spain commences on Friday, the host nation's David Nalbandian will battle the visitors' David Ferrer in the opening singles rubber

Golf Tidbits: Why golf is a gentleman's sport >>
Philadelphia, PA (Sportsbook Betting Lines) - Every sport has its rules. How often people break them depends on the sport. How frequently people call themselves for breaking said rules is a different story. Barry Bonds, Rafael Palmeiro and Mark McGwir

Mussina hangs up spikes after first 20-win season >>
Bronx, NY (Sportsbook Betting Lines) - New York Yankees right-hander Mike Mussina, as expected, retired on Thursday after 18 seasons in the major leagues. Reports circulated on Wednesday that Mussina had decided to call it quits after the fi

Phils' Utley, Feliz need surgery >>
Philadelphia, PA (Sportsbook Betting Lines) - The Philadelphia Phillies announced Thursday that half of its starting infield -- All- Star second baseman Chase Utley and third baseman Pedro Feliz -- will undergo surgery. Utley will have surg

Browns QB Quinn to play despite broken finger >>
Cleveland, OH (Sportsbook Betting Lines) - Cleveland Browns quarterback Brady Quinn has a broken right index finger, but it apparently won't sideline him for Sunday's game against Houston. Quinn, who has started the last two games for the Browns, has


Terrell Owens could return for Cowboys next game
A bye week will allow Terrell Owens broken hand to recover just in time for the next game the Dallas Cowboys are slated to play, according to reports. MySportsbook.com, an football sportsbook, has posted football betting lines on TO playing.

Owens broke the bone leading to his right ring finger Sunday night and had a plate surgically attached to it Monday. Although Owens' hand was swollen and aching Wednesday, Dallas Cowboys coach Bill Parcells said he's optimistic the receiver will be back at work next week and catching passes a week from Sunday against the Tennessee Titans.

MySportsbook.com online sportsbook listed Terrell Owens with odds of 7-2 (or $7 paid out for every $2 bet) to return back for the game against Tennessee.

"I certainly wouldn't rule it out now," Parcells said, referring to Terrell Owens immediate return. "Maybe five days from now I might, but I wouldn't rule it out now. ... I know we're looking to try to get him moving around pretty good in the next day or so. So we'll see where we are."

Owens did not speak with reporters Wednesday, but said Sunday he'd be out two to four weeks. A return against the Titans would be 13 days after the surgery. The Cowboys were listed as an early -7 1/2 favorite vs. the Tennessee Titans for Week 4 at MySportsbook.com

To visit this online sportsbook got to MySportsbook.com for all your Sportsbook accepts Mastercard needs.